Sign up and receive $20 When you reserve & move in with SpareFoot.

Back To Top

Island Storage

171 N Belle Mead Rd, East Setauket NY 11733 1 (844) 611-1271 Map It
Send Me Directions & Hours »
Office Hours
Sun closed
Mon 9:30 am - 6:00 pm
Tue 9:30 am - 6:00 pm
Wed 9:30 am - 6:00 pm
Thu 9:30 am - 6:00 pm
Fri 9:30 am - 6:00 pm
Sat 9:00 am - 5:00 pm
Access Hours
Sun 12:00 am - 11:59 pm
Mon 12:00 am - 11:59 pm
Tue 12:00 am - 11:59 pm
Wed 12:00 am - 11:59 pm
Thu 12:00 am - 11:59 pm
Fri 12:00 am - 11:59 pm
Sat 12:00 am - 11:59 pm
Features / Amenities
  • 24-hour access
  • Free use of truck
  • Video cameras on site
  • Electronic gate access
  • Fenced and lighted
  • Insurance available
  • Insurance required
  • Homeowners/renters insurance accepted
  • 5% military discount (applies to active-duty, reserves, and veterans)
  • 10% student discount
  • 5% senior discount
  • Email billing available
  • Auto-pay available
  • Accepts mail/packages for tenants
  • Moving supplies for sale
  • Spanish speakers on staff
  • Manager lives on-site
  • Rent due on 1st of each month
  • Paperwork can be done remotely
  • Cash accepted
  • Checks accepted
  • Credit cards accepted
  • Visa, mastercard and amex credit cards accepted
  • Vehicle requires title
  • Title must match renter
  • Vehicle must be running
  • Vehicle requires insurance
  • Vehicle requires registration
  • Allow 18-wheeler dropoff
Additional Information from the Facility
We are experiencing high demand in East Setauket. Book today to secure your storage unit.

5' x 5' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Interior,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$79.00
per month

5' x 5' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Drive Up Access,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$89.00
per month

5' x 10' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Interior,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$109.00
per month

5' x 15' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Drive Up Access,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$149.00
per month

10' x 10' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Interior,
  • Roll Up Door,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$149.00
$119.00
per month

10' x 10' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Interior,
  • Roll Up Door,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$149.00
per month

10' x 10' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Drive Up Access,
  • Roll Up Door,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$179.00
per month

10' x 10' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Drive Up Access,
  • Roll Up Door,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$179.00
per month

10' x 10' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Drive Up Access,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$179.00
per month

10' x 20' Unit

  • 10' Ceiling,
  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Drive Up Access,
  • Roll Up Door,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$239.00
$209.00
per month

10' x 20' Unit

  • 10' Ceiling,
  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Drive Up Access,
  • Roll Up Door,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$239.00
per month

10' x 20' Unit

  • 10' Ceiling,
  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Drive Up Access,
  • Roll Up Door,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$239.00
per month

10' x 25' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Drive Up Access,
  • Roll Up Door,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$325.00
per month

10' x 25' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Drive Up Access,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$325.00
per month

10' x 30' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Drive Up Access,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$399.00
per month

10' x 30' Unit

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Drive Up Access,
  • Household Storage Only (No Vehicles)
$399.00
per month

10' x 20' Parking

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Vehicle Storage Only (No Household Items)
$100.00
per month

10' x 20' Parking

  • 24 Hour Access,
  • Vehicle Storage Only (No Household Items)
$109.00
per month
Customer Reviews 10 Reviews
  • 5 star 4
  • 4 star 5
  • 3 star 1
  • 2 star 0
  • 1 star 0
100% of respondents would recommend this facility to a friend.
Pros
  • Good Value (8)
  • Secure (9)
  • Good Service (10)
  • Clean (8)
Cons
  • N/A
Help your fellow storage searchers make the right choice! Leave a Review

3.0 out of 5 stars May. 26, 2015

  Price - 4/5 (Good value)

  Security - 2/5 (Somewhat secure)

  Service - 4/5 (Very helpful)

  Cleanliness - 3/5 (Average)


Recommended: Yes

5.0 out of 5 stars May. 17, 2015

Smooth and convenient to my college, Stony Brook University.

I was met by the assistant manger. All the paper work went smoothly. I moved my College items into my unit. Easy and fast.

  Price - 5/5 (Excellent value)

  Security - 5/5 (Extremely secure)

  Service - 5/5 (Outstanding)

  Cleanliness - 5/5 (Squeaky clean)


Recommended: Yes

4.0 out of 5 stars May. 15, 2015

Pretty good storage

Satisfactory, really helpful management, moving in was really simple

  Price - 4/5 (Good value)

  Security - 4/5 (Very secure)

  Service - 5/5 (Outstanding)

  Cleanliness - 4/5 (Clean)


Recommended: Yes

Comment from Island Storage on May. 16, 2015

thank you Suzanne, i will show this to the team.

5.0 out of 5 stars Apr. 14, 2015

We like this place because customer service is great. It clean also very security we can go in 24 hours per day 7 days a wek

  Price - 5/5 (Excellent value)

  Security - 5/5 (Extremely secure)

  Service - 5/5 (Outstanding)

  Cleanliness - 5/5 (Squeaky clean)


Recommended: Yes

Comment from Island Storage on Apr. 20, 2015

Thank you Dawn, I will pass this on to our staff. as a thank you if you refer a friend to our property and they rent with us will will give you a credit on your account up to $100.00 or 50% of their rental rate. Dave

4.5 out of 5 stars Feb. 3, 2015

Great storage

Manager is really helpful, and the facility is clean, and everything is good.

  Price - 4/5 (Good value)

  Security - 5/5 (Extremely secure)

  Service - 5/5 (Outstanding)

  Cleanliness - 5/5 (Squeaky clean)


Recommended: Yes

4.0 out of 5 stars Nov. 18, 2014

Good service does exist. I'm amazed.

I'm so used to the storage routine but this transaction shined. Great management attitude. They are very helpful. The place is well manicured. I am just entering there but I'm sure my stay will be just as great. I don't usually give top stars but this place is a solid candidate.

  Price - 4/5 (Good value)

  Security - 4/5 (Very secure)

  Service - 5/5 (Outstanding)

  Cleanliness - 5/5 (Squeaky clean)


Recommended: Yes

Comment from Island Storage on Nov. 20, 2014

Thanks Harold for the really nice comment we value our customers and their business. enjoy the Holidays. Dave

4.0 out of 5 stars Sep. 9, 2014

The easiest part of my move and Yves was informative and helpful- a real pleasure.

  Price - 3/5 (Fair price)

  Security - 4/5 (Very secure)

  Service - 5/5 (Outstanding)

  Cleanliness - 4/5 (Clean)


Recommended: Yes

4.0 out of 5 stars Jul. 5, 2014

went well

  Price - 3/5 (Fair price)

  Security - 4/5 (Very secure)

  Service - 4/5 (Very helpful)

  Cleanliness - 3/5 (Average)


Recommended: Yes

5.0 out of 5 stars Sep. 17, 2013

PERFECT

  Price - 5/5 (Excellent value)

  Security - 4/5 (Very secure)

  Service - 5/5 (Outstanding)

  Cleanliness - 5/5 (Squeaky clean)


Recommended: Yes