Coupon IconDeals
tracking-pixeltracking-pixel

Self-storage facilities centered around Shelter Island, NY

How it works

1Select your unit
2Reserve for free
3Visit your facility
4Move in
1 - 15 of 25 storage facilities near Shelter Island, NY
Trusted Partner: Reserve here with confidence, this is one of our most trusted brands.
Prime Storage - Bridgehampton - 229 Butter Lane

Prime Storage - Bridgehampton

Bridgehampton NY 11932|8.9 miles away

5' x 5' Unit
First Month FREE
$75.00
$111.00
5' x 10' Unit
First Month FREE
$86.00
$221.00
10' x 10' Unit
First Month FREE
$172.00
$489.00
View all units
Life Storage - 3181 - Southampton - 59 Mariner Dr - 59 Mariner Drive

Life Storage - 3181 - Southampton - 59 Mariner Dr

Southampton NY 11968|11.9 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
$49.00
$53.00
5' x 15' Unit
$120.00
$131.00
View all units
CubeSmart Self Storage - Southold - 1040 Hortons Ln

CubeSmart Self Storage - Southold

Southold NY 11971|4.9 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
40% Off and First Month Free
$18.60
$31.00
5' x 10' Unit
40% Off and First Month Free
$37.20
$62.00
10' x 10' Unit
40% Off and First Month Free
$130.80
$218.00
View all units
Prime Storage - Bridgehampton - 229 Butter Lane
5 reviews
RECOMMENDED FACILITY
5 reviews
Prime Storage - BridgehamptonBridgehampton NY 119328.9 miles away
View deals
GoodFriend Self-Storage - North Fork - 50 Commerce Drive

GoodFriend Self-Storage - North Fork

Cutchogue NY 11935|8.9 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
First Full Month - 50% Off
$85.00
$100.00
5' x 10' Unit
First Full Month - 50% Off
$119.00
$140.00
10' x 10' Unit
First Full Month - 50% Off
$199.00
$234.00
View all units
Image coming soon

Extra Space Storage - 3180 - Southampton - Mariner Dr

Southampton NY 11968|12 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
$19.00
$20.00
5' x 10' Unit
$47.00
$51.00
10' x 10' Unit
$79.00
$86.00
View all units
Life Storage - 3183 - East Hampton - Hardscrabble Ct - 9 Hardscrable Court

Life Storage - 3183 - East Hampton - Hardscrabble Ct

East Hampton NY 11937|9.9 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
$21.00
5' x 10' Unit
Flash Sale
$44.00
10' x 10' Unit
$168.00
View all units
GoodFriend Self-Storage - East Hampton - 17 Goodfriend Drive

GoodFriend Self-Storage - East Hampton

East Hampton NY 11937|8.6 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
50% off your First Full Month
$119.00
$140.00
10' x 5' Unit
50% off your First Full Month
$159.00
$187.00
View all units
Stonewall Storage - 11900 Oregon Road

Stonewall Storage

Cutchogue NY 11935|9.1 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
2 left at$24.50
$49.00
6' x 8' Unit
$29.50
$59.00
10' x 10' Unit
$104.50
$209.00
View all units
Additional facilities near Shelter Island, NY
Image coming soon

Unit 2 Go

Cutchogue NY 11935|9.1 miles away

View all units
8' x 20' Unit
1 left at$275.00
View all units
Life Storage - 3524 - Riverhead - Enterprise Zone Dr - 1 Enterprise Zone Drive

Life Storage - 3524 - Riverhead - Enterprise Zone Dr

Riverhead NY 11901|19.5 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
$33.00
5' x 10' Unit
Flash Sale
$46.00
10' x 10' Unit
$160.00
View all units
Life Storage - 4183 - Old Saybrook - Spencer Plains Rd - 47 Spencer Plains Road

Life Storage - 4183 - Old Saybrook - Spencer Plains Rd

Old Saybrook CT 06475|15.9 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
$69.00
10' x 5' Unit
$109.00
10' x 10' Unit
$201.00
View all units
CubeSmart Self Storage - Mystic - 868 Flanders Road

CubeSmart Self Storage - Mystic

Mystic CT 06355|27.3 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
10% Off
$39.60
$44.00
5' x 10' Unit
10% Off
$55.80
$62.00
10' x 10' Unit
10% Off
$114.30
$127.00
View all units
Prime Storage - Westhampton Beach - 98 Depot Road

Prime Storage - Westhampton Beach

Westhampton Beach NY 11978|23.2 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
2 left at$70.00
$124.00
5' x 10' Unit
First Month FREE
$138.00
$147.00
10' x 10' Unit
1 left at$239.00
$264.00
View all units
CubeSmart Self Storage - Gales Ferry - 1501 Route 12

CubeSmart Self Storage - Gales Ferry

Gales Ferry CT 06335|27.2 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
25% Off
$36.75
$49.00
5' x 10' Unit
25% Off
$48.75
$65.00
10' x 10' Unit
25% Off
$115.50
$154.00
View all units
Rent-A-Space - East Lyme - Niantic - 9 King Arthur Drive

Rent-A-Space - East Lyme - Niantic

East Lyme CT 06357|21.3 miles away

View all units
5' x 5' Unit
75% Off First 2 Months
$59.00
5' x 10' Unit
75% Off First 2 Months
$79.00
10' x 10' Unit
75% Off First 2 Months
$149.00
View all units
Can't decide? Let SpareFoot help you choose.

Helpful Resources

How Does Self-Storage Work?

First time renting self-storage? Read how it works here.

Storage Unit Size Guide

Find out what size storage unit you need.

Storage Unit Amenities

From climate control to 24-hour access, decide which features you need.

Storage Unit Safety & Security

Learn how storage facilities keep your belongings safe.

Browse Self-Storage Units in Nearby Cities

Filters

Unit size

Amenities