Professional organizers routinely enter client homes where the job ahead is abundantly clear: Some are hopelessly cluttered, others chaotic, and a special few resemble a minefield more than a personal residence.

But you want to know what really messes with an organizer’s mind?

The buttoned-down, perfectly maintained home. LA-based organizer Justin Klosky recalls his first immaculate reception.

“I was referred to this high-end art collector, they had housekeepers and nannies, and when I walked in, their place was immaculate,” he says. “I didn’t want to say to the client, ‘What do you need me for?’ so I said, ‘Well, what can we work on?’”

He didn’t have to wait long for the answer.

Organizer Justin Klosky
Organizer Justin Klosky

“Once we started going through drawers and cabinets and files, it was very easy to see the problem,” he recalls. “I saw everything you could imagine that you could hide behind a door.”

Weeks later, Klosky, who has transformed his own experience with Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD) into a thriving business, had his client’s cabinets in line with their Downton Abbey façade.

“Organized,” he chuckles, “but not OCD organized.”

Top of desk with office equipment arranged if perfect order.

The Difference Between Being OCD and OCPD

While we tend to randomly label neat freaks as OCD, most fall well short of the clinical definition, according to Dr. Jonathan Abramowitz, clinical psychologist and professor/associate chair of the Department of Psychology and Neuroscience at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

“There is a tendency for people to use the term OCD in a colloquial way that kind of misrepresents the clinical syndrome; if you’re a neat freak, you’re OCD. But actually, OCD is usually not about that. What people are describing is more what’s called Obsessive Compulsive Personality Disorder (OCPD), which is very different from OCD,” he says.

“When a person says, ‘I like to keep my house neat and that’s the way I like it and you’re not going to do anything about it and it’s my way or the highway,’ that’s more OCPD,” Abramowitz explains.

With OCD, the person is doing things that they don’t want to be doing: “‘I wish I didn’t have to wash my hands so much or check everything all the time, but I’m afraid if I don’t, someone is going to die or I’m going to get really sick.’”

In fact, the immaculate housekeeper is far more likely to be OCPD than OCD.

“A lot of people with OCD hide it very well; looking around their home, you would never know,” says Dr. Abramowitz. “OCPD is a little more difficult to hide. Those are the people who will say, ‘Oh, you’ve got to take off your shoes before you come in the house’ or ‘You’re not allowed to sit on my couch; it’s just for show.’”

Happy man vacuuming

Too Organized For One’s Own Good?

As much as we all strive toward organization, can a person possibly be too organized for their own good? Dr. Abramowitz didn’t hesitate.

“Oh, sure, you can get caught in the process of organizing to the detriment of the outcome,” Dr. Abramowitz insists. “I like to say that ‘perfect is the enemy of good;’ you can try too hard to make things absolutely perfect, and in doing so, the whole idea of why you wanted to be organized in the first place is lost. But if that’s a disorder, I would classify that more as Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder than OCD.”

But Klosky’s OCD gives him a slightly different take of the question.

“No, I don’t think they can be too organized. They can over-organize in terms of just doing too much to try to support the system that they’re creating because they don’t know what the end goal is. It just depends on your definition. I’m too organized but in a healthy way, where others may be too organized but it’s just distracting for what they’re actually trying to do.”

too organized- find out if your obsession goes too far (1)

 

Even The Over Organized Need Help

Why would a neatnik have need for professional organizing help?

Linda Samuels of Oh, So Organized!, a New York-based professional organizer, has witnessed these five scenarios during her 24-year career:

  • Clutter tolerance: Simply put, we all have different tolerances to physical clutter. “If it looks perfect but feels disorganized, it could be a matter of their tolerance for clutter,” Samuels explains.
  • Couples chaos: One’s a neatnik, the other not so much. “It could be that their spouse or partner has a very different set of standards or expectations, and they really are doing a number on that client to make them feel like they are completely disorganized when they’re not at all,” says Samuels. “In the worst-case scenarios, it almost borders on abuse.”
  • The surprise room: The home is spotless until you enter that one out-of-control room. “They don’t want to show it to you at first because they think you’re going to run screaming from the house,” Samuels says. “They’re used to hiding it; there’s a lot of shame.”
  • Random order: “When the client isn’t necessarily in charge of the daily order of things, in an effort to make everything look good when you walk in, they stuff things in non-logical places; you’ll find clothing and office paper in the kitchen and so on,” Samuels says. “So you tease out the things that don’t belong and set up each room in a way that makes sense.”
  • The seal of approval: Occasionally, a client is so organized that they call in a CPO to check their work. “They basically want the organizer’s seal of approval,” Samuels explains. “They want reassurance that everything they’re doing makes sense and that nothing I could come up with would improve it.”
Jay MacDonald
  • http://www.janetbarclay.com/ Janet Barclay

    While I applaud you for dispelling the myth that someone who prefers order probably has OCD, I take exception to the sentence “the immaculate housekeeper is far more likely to be OCPD than OCD.” They may HAVE OCPD, but the word IS is totally inappropriate. That’s like saying “that woman is cancer, and that man is multiple sclerosis.” No one should be defined by their medical condition.

  • ohsolinda

    Thank you so much, Jay and SpareFoot for including me in this post.

  • http://www.TheSeanaMethod.com/ Seana Turner

    Interesting discussion. I have worked with people who are very organized, but still have way too much stuff. I affirm all of Linda’s scenarios… clutter is really a gateway to so many situations. I also appreciate Janet’s comment as a reminder that we are all fighting our own battles.

  • http://www.sabrinasorganizing.com/blog Sabrina Quairoli

    Over my years as an Organizer, I have seen almost all scenarios Linda mentioned. I never had a person contact me for their seal of approval though. Fascinating.