Storage in Shelter island, NY

Please enable JavaScript for interactive map features.

CubeSmart Self Storage - Southold

1040 Hortons Ln, Southold, NY 11971

4.9 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 3183 - East Hampton - Hardscrabble Ct

9 Hardscrable Court, East Hampton, NY 11937

9.9 miles away

Prime Storage - Bridgehampton

229 Butter Lane, Bridgehampton, NY 11932

8.9 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage - Southold

1040 Hortons Ln, Southold, NY 11971

4.9 miles away

Prime Storage - Cutchogue

50 Commerce Drive, Cutchogue, NY 11935

8.9 miles away

Unit 2 Go

11900 Oregon Road, Cutchogue, NY 11935

9.1 miles away

GoodFriend Self-Storage - East Hampton

17 Goodfriend Drive, East Hampton, NY 11937

8.6 miles away

Stonewall Storage

11900 Oregon Road, Cutchogue, NY 11935

9.1 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage - Old Saybrook - 167-3 Elm Street

55 Research Parkway, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

16.1 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage - CT New London N Frontage RD

391 North Frontage Road, New London, CT 06320

23.9 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage - Gold Star Highway

215 Gold Star Highway, Groton, CT 06340

25.3 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 4183 - Old Saybrook - Spencer Plains Rd

47 Spencer Plains Road, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

15.9 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage - Gales Ferry

1501 Route 12, Gales Ferry, CT 06335

27.2 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage - Old Saybrook - 45 School House Rd

45 School House Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

15.7 miles away

Atrium Storage - 1380 Gold Star Hwy

1380 Gold Star Highway, Groton, CT 06340

27.3 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage - Riverhead

99 Mill Road, Riverhead, NY 11901

21 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage - Mystic CT

868 Flanders Road, Mystic, CT 06355

27.3 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 3524 - Riverhead - Enterprise Zone Dr

1 Enterprise Zone Drive, Riverhead, NY 11901

19.5 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage - CT Old Lyme Shore Rd

232 Shore Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371

15.6 miles away

Prime Storage - Riverhead

209 Marcy Avenue, Riverhead, NY 11901

20.2 miles away

Prime Storage - Westhampton Beach

98 Depot Road, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978

23.2 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 3182 - Hampton Bays - Montauk Hwy

173 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, NY 11946

17 miles away

All-Purpose Storage - Oakdale

430 Chapel Hill Road, Montville, CT 06370

28.7 miles away

A Sure Thing Storage

15 Research Drive, Branford, CT 06405

27.7 miles away

Rent-A-Space - Cross Road

175 Cross Road, Waterford, CT 06385

23.7 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage - Branford

171 Cedar Street, Branford, CT 06405

29.3 miles away

Rent-A-Space - East Lyme - Niantic

9 King Arthur Drive, East Lyme, CT 06357

21.3 miles away

Rent-A-Space - Route 85

934 Hartford Turnpike, Waterford, CT 06385

23.7 miles away

StorQuest - Center Moriches / Frowein

10 Frowein Road, Center Moriches, NY 11934

29.1 miles away

All-Purpose Storage - Uncasville

410 Maple Avenue, Montville, CT 06382

28.5 miles away

Atrium Storage - 1010 Poquonnock Rd

1010 Poquonnock Road, Groton, CT 06340

24.5 miles away

1 - 30 of 30 Storage Facilities in Shelter Island, NY

Sort By:Recommended

Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage - Southold

Trusted Partner Facility

Top-rated facility with exceptional service

4.9 miles away

4.3(10)

CubeSmart Self Storage - Southold

1040 Hortons Ln, Southold, NY, 11971

9.9 miles away

4.5(1)

Extra Space Storage - 3183 - East Hampton - Hardscrabble Ct

9 Hardscrable Court, East Hampton, NY, 11937

Online Move-In Available

View all units

8.9 miles away

4.8(5)

Prime Storage - Bridgehampton

229 Butter Lane, Bridgehampton, NY, 11932

Online Move-In Available

View all units

8.9 miles away

Prime Storage - Cutchogue

50 Commerce Drive, Cutchogue, NY, 11935

Online Move-In Available

View all units

9.1 miles away

Unit 2 Go

11900 Oregon Road, Cutchogue, NY, 11935

No 5' x 5' Units Available

8' x 5'1 Left

$100^.34

No 10' x 10' Units Available

View all units

8.6 miles away

GoodFriend Self-Storage - East Hampton

17 Goodfriend Drive, East Hampton, NY, 11937

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 10'1 Left

$459^.00

View all units

9.1 miles away

5.0(1)

Stonewall Storage

11900 Oregon Road, Cutchogue, NY, 11935

16.1 miles away

4.2(8)

CubeSmart Self Storage - Old Saybrook - 167-3 Elm Street

55 Research Parkway, Old Saybrook, CT, 06475

No 5' x 5' Units Available

23.9 miles away

4.9(7)

CubeSmart Self Storage - CT New London N Frontage RD

391 North Frontage Road, New London, CT, 06320

25.3 miles away

CubeSmart Self Storage - Gold Star Highway

215 Gold Star Highway, Groton, CT, 06340

15.9 miles away

4.8(2)

Extra Space Storage - 4183 - Old Saybrook - Spencer Plains Rd

47 Spencer Plains Road, Old Saybrook, CT, 06475

Online Move-In Available

View all units

Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage - Gales Ferry

27.2 miles away

4.5(53)

CubeSmart Self Storage - Gales Ferry

1501 Route 12, Gales Ferry, CT, 06335

15.7 miles away

4.2(3)

CubeSmart Self Storage - Old Saybrook - 45 School House Rd

45 School House Rd, Old Saybrook, CT, 06475

5' x 5'

$87.00$52^.20

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 10'

$294.00$176^.40

View all units

Photo of Atrium Storage - 1380 Gold Star Hwy

27.3 miles away

5.0(1)

Atrium Storage - 1380 Gold Star Hwy

1380 Gold Star Highway, Groton, CT, 06340

No 5' x 5' Units Available

21 miles away

5.0(2)

CubeSmart Self Storage - Riverhead

99 Mill Road, Riverhead, NY, 11901

27.3 miles away

4.8(16)

CubeSmart Self Storage - Mystic CT

868 Flanders Road, Mystic, CT, 06355

No 5' x 5' Units Available

19.5 miles away

Extra Space Storage - 3524 - Riverhead - Enterprise Zone Dr

1 Enterprise Zone Drive, Riverhead, NY, 11901

No 5' x 5' Units Available

Online Move-In Available

View all units

Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage - CT Old Lyme Shore Rd

15.6 miles away

3.0(1)

CubeSmart Self Storage - CT Old Lyme Shore Rd

232 Shore Road, Old Lyme, CT, 06371

5' x 5'

$36.00$21^.60

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 10'

$119.00$71^.40

View all units

20.2 miles away

5.0(1)

Prime Storage - Riverhead

209 Marcy Avenue, Riverhead, NY, 11901

No 5' x 5' Units Available

Online Move-In Available

View all units

Photo of Prime Storage - Westhampton Beach

23.2 miles away

5.0(5)

Prime Storage - Westhampton Beach

98 Depot Road, Westhampton Beach, NY, 11978

Online Move-In Available

View all units

Photo of Extra Space Storage - 3182 - Hampton Bays - Montauk Hwy

17 miles away

4.0(1)

Extra Space Storage - 3182 - Hampton Bays - Montauk Hwy

173 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, NY, 11946

5' x 5'

$72.00$65^.00

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 10'

$220.00$199^.00

Online Move-In Available

View all units

28.7 miles away

4.5(1)

All-Purpose Storage - Oakdale

430 Chapel Hill Road, Montville, CT, 06370

No 5' x 5' Units Available

27.7 miles away

4.7(3)

A Sure Thing Storage

15 Research Drive, Branford, CT, 06405

No 5' x 5' Units Available

23.7 miles away

4.0(1)

Rent-A-Space - Cross Road

175 Cross Road, Waterford, CT, 06385

Online Move-In Available

View all units

Photo of CubeSmart Self Storage - Branford

29.3 miles away

4.7(11)

CubeSmart Self Storage - Branford

171 Cedar Street, Branford, CT, 06405

21.3 miles away

Rent-A-Space - East Lyme - Niantic

9 King Arthur Drive, East Lyme, CT, 06357

Online Move-In Available

View all units

23.7 miles away

5.0(3)

Rent-A-Space - Route 85

934 Hartford Turnpike, Waterford, CT, 06385

Online Move-In Available

View all units

Photo of StorQuest - Center Moriches / Frowein

29.1 miles away

5.0(1)

StorQuest - Center Moriches / Frowein

10 Frowein Road, Center Moriches, NY, 11934

No 5' x 5' Units Available

No 5' x 10' Units Available

10' x 10'1 Left

$239^.00

View all units

28.5 miles away

All-Purpose Storage - Uncasville

410 Maple Avenue, Montville, CT, 06382

No 5' x 5' Units Available

24.5 miles away

5.0(1)

Atrium Storage - 1010 Poquonnock Rd

1010 Poquonnock Road, Groton, CT, 06340

No 10' x 10' Units Available

View all units

Storage in Shelter island, NY

CubeSmart Self Storage - Southold

Extra Space Storage - 3183 - East Hampton - Hardscrabble Ct

Prime Storage - Bridgehampton

Prime Storage - Cutchogue

Unit 2 Go

GoodFriend Self-Storage - East Hampton

Stonewall Storage

CubeSmart Self Storage - Old Saybrook - 167-3 Elm Street

CubeSmart Self Storage - CT New London N Frontage RD

CubeSmart Self Storage - Gold Star Highway

Extra Space Storage - 4183 - Old Saybrook - Spencer Plains Rd

CubeSmart Self Storage - Gales Ferry

CubeSmart Self Storage - Old Saybrook - 45 School House Rd

Atrium Storage - 1380 Gold Star Hwy

CubeSmart Self Storage - Riverhead

CubeSmart Self Storage - Mystic CT

Extra Space Storage - 3524 - Riverhead - Enterprise Zone Dr

CubeSmart Self Storage - CT Old Lyme Shore Rd

Prime Storage - Riverhead

Prime Storage - Westhampton Beach

Extra Space Storage - 3182 - Hampton Bays - Montauk Hwy

All-Purpose Storage - Oakdale

A Sure Thing Storage

Rent-A-Space - Cross Road

CubeSmart Self Storage - Branford

Rent-A-Space - East Lyme - Niantic

Rent-A-Space - Route 85

StorQuest - Center Moriches / Frowein

All-Purpose Storage - Uncasville

Atrium Storage - 1010 Poquonnock Rd

Helpful Resources

Browse Shelter Island Storage by Amenity

Browse Shelter Island Storage by Unit Size

Storage in nearby cities